The Ministry of Defence (MoD) annually presents its Equipment Plan, a comprehensive outline of its investment in equipment and support projects over the next decade. The recently released Plan for 2023-2033, with a budget allocation of £288.6 billion, highlights a 49% share of the total forecast defence budget. In this article, we summarise the key findings and challenges identified in the report released alongside the Plan.
The Equipment Plan, initiated in 2012, aims to assure Parliament that spending plans are feasible. The National Audit Office annually scrutinizes the MoD's assessment of affordability. The management of equipment programmes involves various Front Line Commands and specialised directorates, collectively known as Top Level Budgets (TLBs).
Affordability Challenges: The 2023-2033 Equipment Plan reveals a significant hurdle, with forecast costs exceeding the budget by £16.9 billion (6%). This marks the largest deficit since the Plan's inception, contrasting with the previous year's surplus. The budget of £288.6 billion faces increased costs primarily in nuclear and naval programmes, with inflation contributing to rising expenses. This isnt really too much of a suprise, given the wider environmental and international factors, but adds a further strain to the industry and our national defence as a whole.
Key Findings:
The MoD estimates a funding gap between £7.6 billion and £29.8 billion, considering potential risks and opportunities.
TLBs employ diverse approaches in preparing forecasts, leading to unaffordable plans for some, while others accept greater risks.
Omitted projects and underfunded initiatives contribute to an underestimation of the overall funding gap.
Factors Contributing to Unaffordability:
The nuclear and naval programs' combined costs have surged by £54.6 billion, with the replacement nuclear deterrent prioritised.
Inflation, impacting all spending areas, poses a significant challenge as the MoD grapples with existing budgets.
Implications and Challenges:
All six TLBs face deficits in their individual equipment plans, with forecast costs exceeding budgets.
Supply chain issues, industry capacity constraints, and delayed project deliveries contribute to short-term savings but pose future cost pressures.
A ringfence around nuclear funding protects a high-priority area but intensifies pressure on excluded programmes.
MoD's Response:
Major decisions on programme cancellations are postponed until after the next Spending Review (largely publicised as "in 2025").
The MoD is considering short-term measures, utilising additional funding for improving resilience and readiness.
Conclusion and Recommendations: The MoD acknowledges the Plan's unaffordability, with a marked deterioration compared to the previous year. Recommendations include assessing the impact of delaying decisions and ensuring consistency in TLBs' approaches for future negotiations with HM Treasury.
In summary, the 2023-2033 Equipment Plan reflects significant financial challenges, prompting the MoD to carefully navigate uncertainties and make strategic decisions to ensure the nation's defense capabilities remain robust.
Futue Challenges: Unfortunately, with the postponement of decisions on programme cancellations, many project and programmes will be uncertain, causing further overspend and delay within the industry. Although no option is a good option, tough decisions will need to be made across the board on priorities and investment, as the stark nature of the current plan shows that some signifcant decisions are due to be made in 2025 - this will inevitably be a point of highly politicised decision making in the lead-up to the elections of 2024.
Full report details can be found here; https://www.nao.org.uk/reports/equipment-plan-2023-to-2033/?utm_source=e-shot&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=TheEquipmentPlan2023to2033
Comments